» español   » euskera   » français   » english


» About Nabarralde

» Subscription

» Map of Navarre

» About Navarre
   History
   Language & Culture
   Adm/Territorial Division

» Navarre papers
   Environment
   History
   Identity
   Patrimony
   Roads
   Sovereignty
   Society
   Symbols
   Women

» Programs
   Special events
   Talks
   Newsletter/Magazine
   Articles distributed
   Content creators

» NA-leku

» Store

» Contact us

Nabarralde | Nabarra Papers

Who starts the forest fires?

Mila Parot Zubimendi.

The cause of this year's fires in the Basque territories remains a subject of heated debate. Environmental activists blamed some local industries for using uncontrolled burning to clear land, while local authorities said the fires were deliberately set by small farmers who burn parcels of land during the winter months to clear them for the following spring. The truth is probably a combination of the two.

Fires in Nabarra

Firefighters try to contain scattered fires in Lapurdi. Forest fires driven by strong winds burnt out hundreds of hectares of scrubland and trees in Nabarra earlier this year. Photo: SudOuest

Most fires in February were started deliberately but journalists chose to focus on the scapegoats, blaming the fires on some individual farmers hoping to plant a few crops or to clear the land for grazing. Those few environmental activists who are taking on the job of investigating some local firms linked to the fires, are enduring a profound sense of alienation.

But the growing hunger for land coincided with strong winds, warm temperatures and dryness due to a lack of rain in the part two months. The fires simply refused to go out. In the past, forest fires have led to the deaths of walkers trapped in the flames.

Forest fires blackened thousands of acres of trees in the Basque territories in France and Spain last February. Hundreds of firefighters worked to contain the scattered fires and some of the blazes, which had been extinguished reignited. Winds speeds were reported at 100-km-per-hour.

The fires reignited a debate in the Basque territories over slash and burn, a practice considered a traditional farming method, though it requires approval by authorities. Land burning is forbidden during periods of dry and windy weather.

Fires were reported in the valleys of Baztan, Malerreka, Bertizarana in residual Nabarra. Government authorities in Nabarra said the fires burnt more land in 72 hours than all the land burnt by fires in the last three years.

Fires were also reported in Karrantza, Lekeitio, Urduliz, Muskiz, Artzentales and Sopuerta in Bizkaia.

Fires blackened hundreds of hectares of trees in the mountains of Lapurdi, Nafarroa Beherea and Zuberoa. Hundreds of firefighters were drafted in from a wide area in an attempt to contain the scattered fires, which in some areas were burning close to residential areas. The fires produced choking haze throughout much of the areas, many of which are rich in biodiversity. Police arrested three people in connection with the fires.

The health impacts of forest fires can be serious and widespread, according to EEPSEA/WWF, as people are in danger of respiratory problems.

Fires in Nabarra

Fires in Nabarra's northern territories blackened hundreds of hectares of trees as strong winds made the blazes difficult to control. Photo courtesy of SudOuest.
Another major consequence of forest fires is their potential impact on global atmospheric problems, including climate change. Only in the past decade have researchers realized the important contributions of biomass burning to the global budgets of carbon dioxide, methane, nitric oxide, tropospheric ozone, methyl chloride and elemental carbon particules.

In many countries, vegetation, forests, savannahs and agricultural lands are burnt to clear land and change its use. Forest clearing accelerates as populations expand and pressures to exploit natural resources increase. Much of the expansion into forested areas uses the cheapest form of cover removal: fire.

Slash and burn farming has a long and successful history in lightly populated forest areas. Provided farmers can leave the land for long enough to recover fully before returning, it does not destroy forest. This may have been the case in the Basque territories. But when migrant farmers move into the forest, things can be very different. They lack the skills to farm the forest successfully, and often there are too many of them allow to forest time to recover. The result is bad for them, their soils and the forests.

To make things worse, December 2000's storms caused the worst damage in a decade in Nabarra's forests (in the northern territories under French administration) to stands of trees, wildlife habitat, buildings, utilities and roads. Wildlife habitat was ravaged in certain areas and wildlife biologists are still assessing the impacts and damages to populations of birds and animals. Current forest management practices prescribe leaving some quantities of dead trees in harvested sites. These trees are nesting sites for birds and animals as well as important sources of biodiversity. The vast quantities of dead -and now burnt- trees could have negative consequences.

While the current trend in the media is to blame the shepherds and small farmers, officialdom may find that the usual media silence and failure to investigate the companies linked to the fires is inadequate to co-opt the growing rage at the grassroots.

July 2002

Mila Parot Zubimendi is a law student and environmental activist. She lives in Miarritze.